Social Icons

twitterfacebookgoogle pluslinkedinrss feedemail

Thursday, April 7, 2011

Boys will be boys: Only if you tell them they have to be.

I am a feminist. Yep, that dirty F word most people cringe at (and they shouldn't, really). It'll be a surprise to most, but feminists are not the hippies they used to be, or if they are, it shouldn't matter.  Let's just say feminism in this century means different things now; the word has evolved, it's taken on a different monster of issues.

There are obviously, many types of feminist definitions and ideals. Because no two women are ever truly the same, I think that it's only necessary that it take on a different meaning. My favorite quote goes a little something like this:



“My idea of feminism is self-determination, and it's very open-ended: every woman has the right to become herself, and do whatever she needs to do.”  (Ani DiFranco)

I love that idea of feminism. The idea of a world where I am able to become whoever I want, however I want, and not be boxed in by rules, guidelines, or by men.  I like that for women, feminism can take on a different shape, a different look. It's not just one small box by which we are trying to cram everyone of us into.  But I also like it because it pretty much applies to everyone, not just me as a woman.

When I had Girlie, my mind raced with all the things she'd have to face. All the issues she'd have to deal with as a woman, a girl. I knew that part of my job as her Mother would be to raise her in such away where she would value herself to challenge our societal norms, and realize that only SHE is the boss of her. I hope, how I hope, that I raise my daughter to be a feminist, in whatever that means for her.

Proudly wearing his Amber Necklace that has garnered criticism from others. 
No one, however has ever spoken to me about the pressure that boys have on them. In fact, I was naive to actually think that boys were in the free and clear, and had it easier. Now, before I get lambasted for that statement, read on, I will explain. What pressure? The pressure to be a boy. That old fashioned, rough and tumble, take no prisoners, be a manly man, sort of boy.  I had no idea this sort of pressure existed.  Boys and girls are pressured to be in this perfect gender box. Girls do this. Girls do that. Boys do this. Boys do that. Girls face issues like being blamed for inviting rape for dressing a specific way (rape is rape, and if I man can't handle himself in such away where he thinks he's welcome to force himself on another human based on clothing, he needs help, thankyouverymuch), or being told they aren't pretty enough. Boys face issues like being stifled in a classroom setting because they are treated as if they won't measure up, or being looked at oddly for taking interest in dance, or societal deemed "girl items". The issues are so very different, but all of them have the same outcome: Putting our kids in tiny little boxes where they are forced to accept that their gender will limit them from experiencing life anyway they wish.

I've been blindsided by the intense gender stereotyping that happens to boys, as my Potato has grown.  When he was around 18 months, Potato developed a love for helping me clean around the house. I searched high and low for pretend cleaning tools, but hit a wall every single time- they were all pink. It made no matter to me if he used something pink, but I refused to play into the stereotype that pretending to clean was only associated with GIRLS.

In that same month, Potato took a love to pushing his stuffed animals around in anything that had wheels, so off I went to find him a doll stroller. Again, I was met with pink, pink and more pink. This time, rolling my eyes, I settled on a pink and blue stroller.  As I brought it out to the car, The Hubby, wide eyed with fear said,

"BUT IT'S PINK!?!" 

I won't relive the entire tongue lashing that I gave him, but essentially, I told him that if Potato was a girl and wanted a pair of hockey sticks, neither the color of the sticks, or the fact that she/he was interested in a primarily male dominated sport would come into play. I told him that we would NEVER be the ones to place stereotypes on our children, and quite frankly, he'd have to get over the pink stroller. 

Since these incidents, I've become a lot more sensitive to the ever growing list of things that society puts out on our children- girls do that, boys do this. There seems to be little wiggle room though for girls at this age. When a girl likes Thomas The Train or Diego, Cars or any boy orientated cartoon, there is no raised eye brows. When a girl wishes to play soccer, or hockey, no one even whispers. As we start getting closer together in demographic, some of the issues that girls face become similar to the ones that are impressed on boys (though they are entirely separate issues).  Then, as both groups grow older, the gender bias starts to become distinctly different for each group. But it's still the same. The idea that our children should behave based on their gender.



"Wow. You're going to want to get that sensitivity stuff under control with him. He's going to end being emo...or worse, GAY!" 

Years ago, some male counterpart said this to me about my sweet Potato. Yes, my child is sensitive, but at the age he was, at a whole whopping 18 months? I was astounded and shocked that a grown adult could view the world so narrowly. I didn't say anything, I sort of shrugged my shoulders and moved on. Honestly, I had no idea what to say, and all I could do was gather my jaw up off the floor so I could walk away.  This was one my first indications that there was some pressure on boys to be a specific way. 

I've since had conversations with people who said they would love their kids differently if they ended up gay, and strive to avoid it (like this is possible). My mind can't even comprehend this logic. It fails to compute. 

 What I fail to understand in this scenario, or with this line of thinking is, "Why does my son being fascinated in the unfamiliar make him likely to 'grow up and be gay'?" Are woman not always complaining that they wish men were more in touch with their feelings, that they had some sensitivity toward the world, and perhaps women in general? Do we not bemoan the male who ends up in a relationship and has been provided with no life skills because he was a boy? (Ahem, The Hubby).  I know when The Hubby and I got together, I was at a loss of all the little things that he had NO idea how to do. Cooking? Not a chance. Properly doing laundry? Nope. Budgeting? Nope. He even struggles with knowing when to be sensitive, and when it's a good time to turn the laugh factory off. I love him, don't get me wrong, but he was raised in a home where the men can leave their plates on the table, but heaven forbid I do it.*

Pretending to nurse; mothering isn't just for mothers. 
So, as adults, if these are the kind of boys we are marrying, the kind that lack sensitivity, who can't fend for themselves without someone caring for them, why do we as a society continue to allow this to happen? Why are we so afraid of a generation of boys who a respectful of women in all ways, that know how to care for themselves, and don't expect women do it for them? We can raise a generation of confident, intelligent boys. Boys who understand and execute empathy, and sympathy. Boys who understand that it's okay to take interest in the more feminine, and it doesn't mean you are gay, or will be gay, or might be weird. 

Obviously, it's not possible to avoid all gender bias. It's bound to happen; I see myself putting Girlie in pink clothes, and searching out "pretty diapers".  Both The Hubby and I have tried, since the Pink Stroller Incident to keep the gender expectations out of the home; our kids are free to grow as they wish, and as they get older, they can indicate their likes and dislikes. Maybe Potato will grow out of this love of baking, and make up, dancing, and pink. Maybe he'll adore baseball or football, and this will be something we remember from when he was a kid. Either way, whatever he becomes, is fine with me. There will be no expectation based on his gender, or sexual preference. He is what he is, and he was born to be whatever he was designed to be. 

I am raising a children who will grow up to be a feminists and will look at their partners as equals. Children who will not consider gender a limitation, and will challenge anyone who decidedly puts them into a confining box based on their sex. 

*This scenario actually occurred. The Hubby comes from a more conservative thinking family when it comes to gender roles, and when I didn't clear my plate on one occasion, I was labelled as lazy. 



5 comments:

  1. Thanks for sharing this! I completely agree. I have a now 7yo son who is quite sensitive and the song "Rock-a-bye Baby" brought him to tears in preschool at the thought of his baby sister falling out of a tree and the mommy no where to be found! He is rough and tumble and finds sticks shaped like guns quicker than you can say "How about a game of tag?!"

    My kids are encouraged to be who they are, like what they like without concern for colors and gender roles. They each have a soft side and they each have a rowdy side - though more often than not, they're both quite rambunctious! In fact, I often say of my kids "I have a 7yo boy and a 4yo girl who thinks she's a 7yo boy."

    ReplyDelete
  2. Shared this on fb and on twitter. We had a friend (male) who kept trying to push guns on my son when he was barely 2. My hubby is a hunter, but I wanted to keep guns out of his hands for as long as possible. The "friend" (and my FIL) would chide me for comforting boo boos - need I say more? Hubby also has had his moments with the girlie stuff (like when I brought home a baby doll, stroller, toy kitchen appliances... He pretty much gave up, except for a little protesting (OK, a lot) when I got a pink dollhouse (which my son loves). Truth is, my son has always loved pink and at one time it was his favorite color. He loves cars and is all boy, but he is also more compassionate than his own father. :-)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Also love the picture of your son pretending to nurse!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Feel free to delete this comment as I could not find an email link - just fyi, I linked to your blog from mine in a post http://maggieorganizingchaos.blogspot.com/2011/04/perfectionism-udder-confusion-pink.html

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have two boys (4 and 1) and have spent quite a bit of time thinking and reading about this as well. Two books I recommend if you're interested- Real Boys by William Pollack and Why Boys Fail (can't remember the author). Real Boys talks a lot about what you're speaking of in gender stereotyping against boys, and Why Boys Fail focuses on how boys are being left behind in school and what we can do to prevent that from happening. There are no easy solutions but the day by day plugging away at each little injustice, really. Sounds like you're doing a marvelous job!

    ReplyDelete